Monday December 22, 2008 – Stewart Wolpin
A consumer goes into a store to buy a camcorder. On one shelf are AVCHD or HDV camcorders from Sony, Canon, JVC, Panasonic and Samsung, which list for around $1,000.
On another nearby shelf are HD camcorders that are $250 or less, are about the size of a deck of cards, and look (and are) really simple to operate.
The consumer knows that the Sony, Canon, JVC, Panasonic and Samsung camcorders are better. But four times better?
I'm willing to bet two things. First, these cheap HD camcorders will sell as well if not better than traditional HD camcorders in Q4 in the U.S., and, second, they will come to dominate the worldwide camcorder business in the coming years.
Traditional camcorder manufacturers derisively refer to these cheap camcorders as "toys." But this dismissive attitude sounds achingly familiar to the way the Big 3 automakers dismissed the then-new tiny gas-efficient foreign imports back in the day. We all know how that hubristic attitude worked out.
These "toy" HD camcorders are a relatively new phenomena and their availability is mostly confined to the U.S. market at the moment. It's only been in the last month or so that Creative Labs announced its Vado ($229.99) and Flip its MinoHD ($229.99), and Kodak started selling its Zi6 ($179.95), all of which join the previously introduced DXG 567V ($179). All capture either 720p or 1080i video using H.264 compression to flash memory, either built-in, to a removable SD card, or both, run on a couple of AAs, have a tiny LCD view screen, a flip-out USB jack for simple PC/Mac connections and cheap plastic lenses.
These four models are likely to be joined by others from other manufactures, some well-known some unknown, and likely none from Sony, et al. As time goes on, flash-based "toys" will not only outsell higher-end HD camcorders, but $250-plus standard definition models from Sony, et al, as well. In a couple of years or so, standard definition camcorders will disappear and the all-HD camcorder market is likely to split similarly to the digital camera world. These HD "toys" will become the predominant point-and-shoot market while HD models from Sony, et al, become the analogous D-SLR high-end.
Like the digital camera world, consumers know that HD camcorders from Sony, et al, capture far higher quality video. But for a quarter of the price and point-and-shoot operational simplicity, the video these new "toy" camcorders capture will more than just suffice, and will become the camcorder business.